Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed November 5, 2026
OXO vs Wilton Cookie Press: Pick Your Spritz Patterns
Count the patterns, not the pieces: the 14-piece OXO Good Grips and the 13-piece Wilton Simple Success each make 12 designs. OXO counts a case for its stainless steel disks. Choose it for flowers, leaves and a large lever you push down. Choose Wilton for a squeeze trigger and shapes such as pumpkins and turkeys. If the family recipe starts with rolling out chilled dough, keep the cookie cutters; neither press is a shortcut for that job.
Best for
Bakers making small butter cookies from a spritz recipe who want several shapes from the same dough without rolling and cutting it.
Probably not for
Cutout cookies for detailed icing, chocolate-chip drop cookies, or anyone wanting to write with frosting: those jobs need different tools.
Specifications at a glance
| What differs | OXO Good Grips 14-piece | Wilton Simple Success 13-piece |
|---|---|---|
| Model on US listing | 1257580 | 2104-2627 (Wilton SKU 191001676) |
| Pressing motion | Push down on a large lever; non-slip base | Squeeze a soft-grip trigger toward the handle |
| Included patterns | 12 stainless steel disks with a disk storage case | 12 disks with the press |
| Distinctive examples | Daisy, sunflower, bear, butterfly, leaf, snowflake | Pumpkin, turkey, snowman, pinwheel, doily, starburst |
| Refill cue | Clear barrel | Clear barrel |
| Washing instructions | Barrel, bottom ring and disks can go in the dishwasher; hand-wash top and plunger | Wash press by hand; model instructions allow the barrel in the dishwasher |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
OXO Good Grips 14-Piece Cookie Press Set, 1257580
OXO pairs its lever-operated press with twelve steel disks and a case sized for them. It makes particular sense for someone who bakes in different seasons: a butterfly for spring and a snowflake for winter can live side by side until needed. The case is for the disks, though. You still need a place for the press itself.
Pros
- Included case keeps the small steel disks together between batches
- Large lever offers a downward pressing motion rather than a finger squeeze
Cons
- No turkey or pumpkin in the base set
- Top and plunger still need hand-washing
Who it’s for: Pick OXO if its flower and nature shapes are the ones your household will use, or if you want to put the working disks through the dishwasher. Skip it if the seasonal design you came for is only pictured in a separate set.
Check OXO Good Grips 14-Piece Cookie Press Set, 1257580 on Amazon Paid linkWilton Simple Success 13-Piece Cookie Press, 2104-2627
Wilton’s squeeze trigger and its autumn and winter shapes give it a distinct purpose. A Thanksgiving box can include a pumpkin and a turkey without an extra disk purchase; switch to the doily or pinwheel for a tray that does not mark a holiday. A tree and wreath are in the box too, so choosing the autumn designs does not mean giving up those two winter staples.
Pros
- Both pumpkin and turkey patterns in the standard set
- Soft-grip trigger suits a baker who likes closing a handle to dispense dough
Cons
- No separate disk case listed with the 13 pieces
- Rod must be turned to the pressing position after filling
Who it’s for: Pick Simple Success if its shapes match your baking calendar and squeezing a trigger feels natural. Pass if your main requirement is a downward lever, or you specifically want OXO’s bear, leaf or butterfly.
Check Wilton Simple Success 13-Piece Cookie Press, 2104-2627 on Amazon Paid linkStart with the cookie you want to give someone
Imagine opening a tin and finding a row of leaves, a row of daisies and a row of little bears. OXO can make that assortment from its base set. Change the gift to a Thanksgiving place setting with a turkey beside each name card, and Wilton is the match. For a December box of trees, wreaths and hearts, either set covers the assignment. At that point you can stop comparing pictures of disks and choose on the handle and cleanup.
A disk shapes the dough as it passes through holes. It does not cut an outline from a rolled sheet, and it is not a stamp that you press into an existing cookie. Consider where your decoration goes: a little colored sugar on a ridged spritz is one project; writing a name across a large flat mitten cookie is another. For the mitten, choose a cutter with enough room for the lettering. For ordinary dough studded with chocolate chunks, a press is the wrong route entirely. The OXO vs Norpro cookie scoop guide covers portioning drop dough without feeding it through small openings.
A lever, a trigger and what happens between refills
The two presses meet the pan in much the same way. The base sits on the sheet, dough passes through the disk, and you lift the press to leave the cookie behind. It is what your hand does above the pan that differs. With OXO, one hand can steady the body while the other pushes the lever down. With Wilton, your fingers close the trigger toward the handle. If you can handle a display model, try the motion with the base resting at your usual counter height. Waving an empty press in the air tells you little about where your wrist and elbow will sit over a tray.
The refill sequence is another useful distinction. OXO has a release button for drawing up the plunger; the top twists off to load the barrel. On the Wilton, you turn the rod so its teeth face away from the handle, pull it up and load the dough through the bottom. Turn the teeth back toward the handle for pressing. If the Wilton trigger moves but the rod does not advance after a refill, check that setting before squeezing harder. With the OXO, prime the lever until the disk fills evenly before judging the first impression.
Give the dough a surface it can hold on to
A spritz cookie has to stay on the pan when you lift the tool. That makes some familiar baking habits unhelpful here. Wilton’s instructions for this specific model call for a cooled, ungreased aluminum sheet and rule out parchment and nonstick pans. OXO’s booklet also calls for an ungreased sheet that is cool or at room temperature. If you own several sheets, start with the plain one that meets your press instructions. The Nordic Ware vs USA Pan half-sheet comparison distinguishes uncoated aluminum from a coated surface if you are sorting out what is already in the cupboard.
Use a recipe written for a cookie press for the first batch. A dough log in the refrigerator is not necessarily spritz dough just because it fits through the filling opening. When the first shape lifts off with the tool, look at the sheet for grease and check that the base is sitting flat. If dough will barely move at all, check its temperature against the recipe and look for a blocked disk. These are different problems. Adding another squeeze to a cookie that would not stick does not fix the surface it was supposed to land on.
For two trays, one plain metal sheet and one lined sheet do not give you two equivalent pressing surfaces. If you only have one suitable sheet, let it cool between rounds. Pick your next disk or decorate the cooled cookies during that pause instead of trying to press the next row onto a hot pan.
Organize the shapes before you add the dough
Lay the disks for today’s cookies in a small dish and leave the rest put away. For several patterns in one color, run a row of one shape before changing disks; you can see how many of each design you have without counting the whole sheet. When making several colors of one shape, plan the barrel changes instead. A little dark dough left behind the disk will show up in the next pale batch. For a crisp color change, clear the ring and disk as well as the visible barrel.
After baking, separate the ring and disk so dough does not dry between them. The OXO instructions give dishwasher permission to the barrel, bottom ring and disks, not the lever assembly. Wilton tells you to wash the press in warm soapy water; its model instructions permit the barrel in the dishwasher. Dry the parts before putting them away. For Wilton, a labeled envelope or small container for the dry disks gives the whole set a place in the drawer. For OXO, put the dry disks back in their case and store it beside the press. That way next season’s first decision is which shape to make, not which press a loose disk belongs to.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 5, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- OXO: Good Grips 1257580 base set, mechanism, disk designs and case
- OXO: loading, priming, baking-sheet preparation and care by part (PDF)
- Wilton: Simple Success SKU 191001676, trigger, included designs and care
- Wilton: model 2104-2627 instructions for the rod, aluminum sheet and washable barrel (PDF)
- Amazon US: OXO 14-piece set with disk case, model 1257580 Paid link
- Amazon US: Wilton Simple Success 13-piece press and disks, model 2104-2627 Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.