Cycling Gear Comparisons · Reviewed November 10, 2026
Shimano SM-SH51 vs SM-SH56: Single or Multi-Release?
Choose the black SM-SH51 if you want one deliberate exit: turn your heel away from the bike. Choose the silver SM-SH56 if you want a heel twist in either direction, or a lift combined with a twist, to let you out. The SH56 is not for riders who pull up on their pedals or jump. Both are two-bolt SPD cleats with the same listed float. Neither is designed to release automatically in a fall.
Best for
A rider with SPD-compatible shoes and pedals who is buying replacement cleats or deciding whether to change the release motion on a familiar bike.
Probably not for
SPD-SL road pedals, shoes that only accept a three-bolt cleat, or anyone who wants to be able to lift a foot off the pedal freely without unclipping.
Specifications at a glance
| What to check | SM-SH51 | SM-SH56 |
|---|---|---|
| Retail pair compared | ISMSH51, black, without cleat nut | ISMSH56, silver, without cleat nut |
| Shoe interface | Two-bolt SPD | Two-bolt SPD |
| Exit motion | Twist the heel outward | Twist either way, or lift and twist the heel |
| Float while engaged | 4 degrees | 4 degrees |
| Listed clip-out angle | 13 degrees | 13 degrees |
| Upward load | An upward pull alone is not the release motion | Can release under upward load; not for pulling up or jumps |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Shimano SM-SH51 single-release SPD cleats, black pair
This two-bolt steel cleat opens the binding when the rider turns the heel outward. The ISMSH51 package is the version without a cleat nut.
Pros
- Outward twist gives both feet one exit motion to learn
- Does not add an upward exit for riders who load the pedal on the upstroke
Cons
- Lifting the heel is not a substitute for turning it outward
- Does not solve a stop-and-start rider’s need for more than one release direction
Who it’s for: Buy it to keep a familiar outward release, especially if lifting on the pedals is part of how you ride.
Check Shimano SM-SH51 single-release SPD cleats, black pair on Amazon Paid linkShimano SM-SH56 multi-release SPD cleats, silver pair
The ISMSH56 pair uses the same two-bolt mounting system and allows additional ways out of a compatible binding. It also comes without a cleat nut.
Pros
- Adds an inward twist and a lifting-and-twisting exit
- Offers the extra release directions without changing the listed float
Cons
- Upward pedaling or jumping can cause an unintended release
- Multiple release directions still require practice and do not guarantee release in a fall
Who it’s for: Buy it if extra ways to step out suit your stops and your riding does not involve pulling up on the pedals.
Check Shimano SM-SH56 multi-release SPD cleats, silver pair on Amazon Paid linkTwo questions to ask before taking the shoes off the shelf
Imagine two people arriving at the same trail gate. The first rider wants to keep a foot attached while pulling up on a steep approach and already turns a heel outward well before stopping. The second rolls along a level towpath, stopping often for gates and pedestrians. That rider wants more than one way to step out. Both might describe their outing as a gravel ride. What their feet do on the way to the gate gives a better answer than the name on the route map: the SH51 fits the first request, the SH56 the second.
Now ask what equipment is already there. You need two matches: the cleat has to bolt to the shoe and the pedal has to accept that specific cleat. A shoe with an SPD-compatible two-bolt mount clears the first hurdle only. Look up the pedal model on the bike, especially on a secondhand bike or one at a cycling studio. Two riders can wear the same shoe and need different cleats for their respective bikes. A three-bolt-only road shoe or an SPD-SL pedal takes this pair out of consideration.
Why the two angles on the box do not settle the choice
Float is the small amount of movement available to your foot while it remains clipped in. Release is the point at which you can take the shoe away from the binding. Shimano lists four degrees of float and a thirteen-degree clip-out angle for each model. If your complaint is too little movement while pedaling, buying the SH56 for “more movement” mixes up the two measurements. You would still be buying the same listed float. The difference becomes useful when you mean to leave the pedal, not while you are turning an ordinary seated pedal stroke.
Spring tension is a third matter. On an adjustable SPD pedal it affects the force needed to get out; it does not cut a new release path into the cleat. Backing off the spring on an SH51 setup will not give it the SH56’s lift-and-twist action. Conversely, tightening a pedal does not turn the SH56 into the SH51 for a day of jumping. If one shoe has recently become harder to release than the other, identify that as a change in how the equipment works before treating it as a preference for another cleat design.
A stop-heavy ride favors advance planning with either cleat
Picture making a tight turn at the end of a path where the gate may be locked. With the SH51, plan the outward turn of the heel before the bike gets so slow that you have to put a foot down immediately. With the SH56 you have additional deliberate exits, but the locked gate is still the wrong place to try one for the first time. In either case, setting a foot free on the approach buys more time than waiting to discover which way your heel moves when the bike is already tipping.
Shimano’s practice sequence starts with the brakes held and one foot planted. Engage and release the other shoe, then swap sides. Only take that practice onto level ground once both feet can repeat the motion reliably. It is worth noticing an asymmetry here: if the left foot is the one you always put down, the right may feel unfamiliar even with an identical cleat. Practice with the right as well. If you would rather be able to put either foot straight down without thinking about any release motion at all, ordinary flat pedals better match that request.
When an extra way out is a disadvantage
On a climb, think about the foot coming up as much as the foot pushing down. If you deliberately pull against the binding on that upstroke, the SH56’s extra release direction works against you. Shimano specifically rules out this cleat for pulling up and for jumps. The same warning applies if most of your miles are gentle but you regularly finish the route with a section that demands that movement. Count the exception when choosing the cleat; the shoe you put on for the towpath is still the one attached to the pedal at the end.
The SH51 is the relevant one of these two for a rider who wants the pedal to stay engaged during an upward pull. It is not a lock. A heel that twists outward during a hard effort can still release it. Nor should a rider count on either cleat opening when the bike falls over. If clipping out is inconsistent while the bike is stationary, leave the harder riding for another day. An unexpected release and a failure to release are both reasons to inspect the setup, not opposing problems that cancel each other out.
Read the small part number if the shoes are new to you
The exact packages here are ISMSH51 and ISMSH56. Both omit the cleat nut, the threaded piece on the shoe side that receives the mounting bolts. That is different from the metal cleat you see on the underside. Shimano also catalogs versions with that nut, distinguished by an A at the end of the part number. On a shoe already set up for SPD, check that the fitting is present and in good condition; with a bare or used shoe, do not assume the previous owner left everything in place. A new cleat pair cannot supply a part the package explicitly omits.
A separate case is the rider setting up an entirely new pair of pedals. Check the pedal box before ordering anything extra. For example, Shimano lists a pair of SH51 cleats with its PD-M520 pedals. If outward release is the aim, that pair may already answer the question. If you are also changing the pedals on the crank, the 15 mm pedal wrench comparison explains which pedal axles those tools fit. Replacing cleats on a shoe does not by itself require removing the pedals from the bike.
Replace a worn cleat without accidentally changing the ride
Before undoing an old pair that fitted well, photograph each sole straight on so you can refer back to the cleat’s position and angle. Read the model marking instead of trying to judge a scuffed cleat by its color. If the previous arrangement released just the way you liked until recently, replacing like with like is a useful starting point. Check for dirt in the binding and wear or loose hardware as well. A newly reluctant release after a muddy ride does not, by itself, mean you bought the wrong release mode.
For a shoe adjustment away from home, the Park Tool IB-2 and Crankbrothers M17 guide lists the hex keys each carries. Having a fitting key and achieving the manufacturer’s specified mounting torque are different things; use the setup instructions for the shoe and pedal or have a shop do the fitting. Recheck engagement and release on both sides before riding. The useful result is not a different number printed on the shoe. It is being able to describe exactly how you will put a foot down at the next gate and knowing the binding behaves that way.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 10, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Shimano: SM-SH51 shoe mount, float and clip-out angle
- Shimano: SM-SH56 release options and specifications
- Shimano SPD pedal user manual: release motions, upward load, practice and inspection
- Shimano parts catalog: retail codes with and without cleat nuts
- Shimano: SH51 cleats supplied with PD-M520 pedals
- Amazon U.S.: Shimano SPD single-direction release set SM-SH51 Paid link
- Amazon U.S.: Shimano SPD multi-directional release set SM-SH56 Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.