Bakeware Comparisons · Reviewed November 13, 2026
USA Pan 1152FR vs 1151IT: Baguette or Italian Loaf Pan?
Choose the 1152FR when you want three slender baguettes for crostini, cheese boards or sharing. Choose the 1151IT when you want two broader loaves to split for sandwiches or garlic bread. Both are 16 inches long, perforated and limited to 450°F. The difference is how much room each loaf gets across the pan.
Best for
Home bakers who regularly shape long loaves, have a recipe at or below 450°F and want side support for the dough.
Probably not for
Pourable batters, full-length bakery baguettes longer than the pan, square sandwich slices or recipes that require these pans to go into an oven above 450°F.
Specifications at a glance
| What changes in the kitchen | 1152FR French Baguette Pan | 1151IT Italian Loaf Pan |
|---|---|---|
| Long loaves per batch | 3 narrow wells | 2 broader wells |
| Length of each well | 16 inches | 16 inches |
| Width of each well | 3 1/8 inches | Over 4 inches; exact width differs between maker specifications |
| Pan depth | About 1 3/16 inches | 2 inches |
| Bread contact surface | Perforated; nonstick silicone coating | Perforated; nonstick silicone coating |
| Maximum oven setting | 450°F | 450°F |
| Cleaning and utensils | Hand wash; silicone, nylon or wood | Hand wash; silicone, nylon or wood |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
USA Pan 1152FR French Baguette Pan, 3 Loaves
One shallow pan with three side-by-side curved wells. Each is 16 inches long and 3 1/8 inches across.
Pros
- Accommodates three separately shaped baguettes together
- Slim profile suits small rounds for appetizers
Cons
- Narrow channels leave less room for a broad sandwich loaf
- The pan cannot take a recipe that requires 475°F
Who it’s for: For the baker who divides dough into three long pieces and wants smaller slices or whole loaves to give away.
Check USA Pan 1152FR French Baguette Pan, 3 Loaves on Amazon Paid linkUSA Pan 1151IT Italian Bread Loaf Pan, 2 Loaves
Two wider channels share a perforated base. The listed depth is two inches, with the same 16-inch working length as the French pan.
Pros
- Broader loaves give toppings a wider base
- A two-piece recipe needs no third portion to fill the pan
Cons
- Only two full-length pieces fit per load
- Published width measurements conflict, which matters for a close fit
Who it’s for: For the baker who wants a pair of lengthwise-split loaves, one to serve and one to save.
Check USA Pan 1151IT Italian Bread Loaf Pan, 2 Loaves on Amazon Paid linkPick the pan by what goes on a slice
For a tray of appetizers, work backward from the topping. A spoonful of tapenade sits nicely on a small round that a guest can pick up in one hand. Three slender baguettes from the 1152FR give you three sets of those small rounds, and you can leave the third loaf whole until you know you need it. For a platter of garlic bread, the useful surface is the long cut face. Two broader loaves from the 1151IT give you four generous halves to spread before cutting them into portions.
Suppose you are packing sandwiches with slices of mozzarella and tomato. A broad loaf lets those rounds lie closer to flat instead of overlapping in a narrow row. That is a reason to favor the Italian pan, not a rule about what belongs in French or Italian bread. For soup and cheese, the opposite can be true: slim pieces cut across the loaf may be just what you want. The same dough can serve either meal, but it is worth buying the shape you would miss more often.
Neither well is a mold for an exact finished slice. USA Pan measures the baking surface, not the diameter of your bread. Shaping, the amount of dough and how far it rises will still affect the result. A baker looking for a flat top and four straight sides for lunchbox sandwiches wants a different kind of pan altogether. The USA Pan Pullman loaf pan comparison explains the sizes of the lidded rectangular alternative.
Divide your usual dough before counting the wells
If you already have a recipe you like, start with its yield. A recipe for three baguettes aligns with three wells when the shaped length also fits. King Arthur Baking, for example, gives a 15- to 18-inch length range for its French-Style Baguettes and allows either a baguette pan or a baking sheet. With the 16-inch USA Pan, the short end of that range makes sense. Rolling each piece all the way out to 18 inches would leave you with bread longer than its support.
Now imagine 900 grams of mixed dough on the counter. Dividing it into three means 300 grams per piece; dividing it into two means 450 grams. That is half again as much dough in each piece, even though there is not one gram more bread in the batch. Those figures illustrate portioning, not a capacity rating for either pan. Start with a recipe designed for the intended loaf size rather than assuming that a pan with two wells holds exactly as much dough as the pan with three.
There is also a timing cost to buying fewer wells than your recipe uses. If three 15-inch loaves are ready to bake at the same time, only two fit in the 1151IT. You would need another suitable surface or a plan for a second bake. Conversely, a two-loaf household need not split a favorite dough into thirds just to occupy the third channel on the 1152FR. An unused well is fine; narrower bread may be the real drawback.
What the perforations do, and what they cannot contain
Each pan supports the underside and flanks of a shaped piece of dough. The little openings let hot air reach the bread where a solid trough would block it. That shared design is a reason to consider either pan; it is not evidence that one will brown faster than the other. The loaf size changes at the same time as the pan. A timetable for three thin baguettes is not a reliable promise for two thicker loaves, even if the ingredient list is identical.
Picture the dough just after shaping. If you can lift a long piece from the counter and set it in a channel, the pan has something to support. If the recipe tells you to pour the mixture from a bowl, you have a containment problem the channels cannot solve. Banana bread batter, for example, needs a solid-sided pan. Lining a perforated well to catch batter also covers the openings you bought it for, without turning the open ends into walls.
For a first attempt at baguettes, check whether the recipe already offers a flat baking sheet option. The King Arthur recipe does. A tray you own gives you room to experiment with loaf length before committing cupboard space to a fixed shape. The argument for a perforated pan gets stronger when you know you like the recipe, repeat it often, and want each shaped piece to have its own curved support. It gets weaker if the next batch is as likely to be round boules as long loaves.
Check the rack, the recipe temperature and the cupboard
Both pans are 16 inches long. In a compact oven, use the actual rack at the height where the bread will bake, not the width of the appliance door. With the oven cold, use a paper outline to check the usable area, then remove it. A pan that fits left to right may not fit front to back; the closed door, fan housing and the clearances specified for your oven can change the answer. On the French pan, the outer width is 9 1/2 inches, wider than the Italian pan despite its narrower loaves.
If half an inch would decide the fit, there is one detail worth checking with the seller. USA Pan gives the Italian model as 8 1/2 inches wide in its main details and 8 inches in a second specification block. The two blocks also disagree on the exact well width. Both describe two wells wider than four inches and a depth of two inches. That is enough information to choose a loaf profile, but not enough to promise clearance on a shelf with an 8 1/4-inch opening.
The temperature check is simpler: 450°F is the ceiling for both pans. Read the preheat step as well as the line about baking. A recipe that starts in a 475°F oven and drops to 425°F after loading still asks the pan to go into an oven above its limit. Choose a compatible recipe or a different baking surface for that method. Buying the shallower French pan instead of the Italian one does not buy an extra 25 degrees.
From the shaping bench to the bread board
A bench scraper belongs beside the mixing bowl, not against the coated pan. Use it on the worktop to divide the dough, then shape each piece there before moving it to a well. The OXO and Mercer bench scraper comparison looks at the handles and blade markings that matter for that job. Once the dough is in a channel, USA Pan calls for silicone, nylon or wooden utensils on the bakeware. Take finished loaves to a board before sawing off the first slice.
Neither pan needs its own special cleaning kit. USA Pan recommends washing by hand in warm soapy water and advises against cooking spray. That matters if the normal routine in your kitchen is to coat every tin with aerosol spray and send it through the dishwasher. Follow the preparation called for in a compatible bread recipe, let the pan cool before washing and take a moment to check the openings for crumbs. A pan that will always be left at the bottom of the washing-up pile is a poor everyday choice, however good its shape looks on paper.
For a final tie-breaker, count destinations as well as portions. If one loaf stays home and two go to neighbors, the 1152FR gives each household a whole baguette without a cut end. If you want one substantial loaf alongside dinner and a second to split for sandwiches tomorrow, the 1151IT does the job in two pieces. If you cannot name the next meal for either shape, bake one batch on the sheet you already have. The bread you actually cut and serve will tell you more than a photograph of an empty pan.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 13, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- USA Pan: 1152FR-1 French Baguette Pan dimensions, use and care
- USA Pan: 1151IT-1 Italian Bread Loaf Pan dimensions, use and care
- King Arthur Baking: French-Style Baguettes yield, shaping length and baking surfaces
- Amazon US: USA Pan Bakeware Aluminum Perforated Nonstick French Baguette Bread Pan, 3-Loaf Paid link
- Amazon US: USA Pan Aluminum Nonstick Perforated Italian Loaf Pan, 2-Well Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.